Please note: In 2003, the CTF updated its Grades of Recommendations to include an "I Recommendation" for situations where insufficient evidence exists to allow a recommendation to be made. (Formerly, these situations were captured under a "C Recommendation".) This change is not retroactive, and all "C Recommendations" made prior to 2003 have not been reevaluated in light of the new "I" recommendation grade. For a discussion of these recommendation grades, please link to the 2003 article in the Canadian Medical Association Journal here.
Contents
In its 1979 report, the Canadian Task Force on the Periodic Health Examination reviewed the available evidence and concluded that there was no scientific evidence to support screening for thalassemia in the general population, but that there was fair evidence to support screening of people of Asian, African, and Mediterranean ancestry.< 1> This chapter updates the earlier report in the light of further publications and technological advances and extends its scope to consider screening for other hemoglobinopathies, including sickle cell disease.
Based on this updated review the Task Force concludes that 1) there is fair evidence to support selective prenatal screening of pregnant women from high risk groups (African, Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, East Indian, Hispanic and Southeast Asian ancestry) (B Recommendation); 2) there is fair evidence to offer DNA analysis of amniotic fluid or chorionic villus samples when both parents have established positive carrier status (B Recommendation); 3) there is good evidence to recommend screening to identify high-risk neonates (A Recommendation). Whether such screening should be applied universally or targeted to identified high risk groups should depend on the demographics of the population being screened; 4) there is insufficient evidence to recommend for or against screening and counselling non-pregnant adolescents and adults for carrier status (C Recommendation). All screening efforts must be accompanied by comprehensive counselling and treatment services.
Burden
of SufferingThe b-thalassemias occur among individuals of East Indian, Mediterranean, African, Middle Eastern, Southeast Asian or Hispanic origin, and the proportion of such individuals in the Canadian population is increasing. For example, among Ontario’s population of approximately 10 million, about 20% are of African, Southeast Asian, Mediterranean or Middle Eastern ancestry – all groups in which the incidence of hemoglobinopathies is relatively high. Over 130 b-thalassemia mutations have been described.
a-thalassemias result from deletions in 1 or more of the 4 genes responsible for a-globin synthesis. They are common in persons of Southeast Asian descent, but also occur in persons of African and Mediterranean origin. Fetuses with a 4-gene deletion develop hydrops fetalis secondary to severe anemia and die before or soon after birth. Mothers of these infants are at risk for toxemia during pregnancy, for operative delivery, and for post-partum hemorrhage. The three-gene deletion is referred to as Hemoglobin H disease and affects about 1% of Southeast Asians. Persons with Hemoglobin H disease experience chronic hemolytic anemia that is exacerbated by exposure to oxidants and may require transfusion. Persons with a two-gene deletion have microcytic red blood cells and occasionally mild anemia. The one-gene deletion is a "silent" carrier state. These latter two conditions are often called a-thalassemia trait. The exact prevalence of a-thalassemia is uncertain, but is estimated to be 5-30% among African-Americans, and 15-30% among Southeast Asians.
Hemoglobin E trait is the third most common hemoglobin disorder in the world and the most frequent in Southeast Asia, where its prevalence is estimated to be 30%. Although Hemoglobin E trait is associated with no morbidity, the offspring of individuals who carry this hemoglobin variant may exhibit thalassemia major (hemoglobin E/b-thalassemia) if the other parent has b-thalassemia trait and contributes that gene. This combination is the most common cause of transfusion-dependent thalassemia in areas of Southeast Asia.
Mortality in patients with sickle cell disease peaks between 1 and 3 years of age, chiefly due to sepsis caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae, estimated to occur in a frequency of 8 episodes per 100 person-years of observation in affected children under 3 years of age.
After infancy, patients with sickle cell disease are usually anemic and may experience painful crises and other complications, including acute chest syndrome, strokes, splenic and renal dysfunction, bone and joint symptoms, priapism, ischemic ulcers, cholecystitis and hepatic dysfunction associated with cholelithiasis.
Less severe but similar symptoms may be experienced by persons heterozygous for hemoglobin-S and hemoglobin-C (Hb SC) and those heterozygous for hemoglobin-S and b-thalassemia (HbS/b-thal). It has recently been reported that individuals with sickle cell trait have increased susceptibility to death from exertional heat illness during military training. Otherwise, morbidity for such individuals has been considered to be negligible.
ManeuverBlood for screening for carrier states is collected in heparinized tubes. For newborn screening, capillary blood is collected on filter paper (Guthrie paper blotter). Cellulose acetate electrophoresis, or thin layer isoelectric focusing are the preferred screening tests for hemoglobin disorders. Cellulose acetate electrophoresis is not specific for HbS if used alone. Citrate agar electrophoresis is used by many laboratories to confirm the presence of abnormal hemoglobins detected by another technique. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is a newer technique that offers higher resolution than 2-tier electrophoresis.
In over two million automated HPLC screening tests carried out in California between 1990 and 1993, only 1 false positive and 1 false negative test have been recorded (unpublished report). Newer techniques, employing monoclonal antibodies and recombinant DNA technology may be used more widely in the future.
Electrophoresis is highly specific in the detection of certain hemoglobin disorders, such as sickle cell disease. In one study, all 138 children with hemoglobin S identified in screening 2,976 African-american newborns were found to have a sickling disorder when retested at age 3-5 years.<3> Another study of 131 infants detected by screening found only nine instances in which the sickling disorder required reclassification and no instance in which a child originally diagnosed as having sickle cell disease was found to have sickle cell trait.<4> Ten years’ experience with universal screening of Colorado newborns (528,711) using filter paper specimens and two-tier hemoglobin electrophoresis was recently reported.<5> Fifty infants with sickle cell diseases (HbSS, HbSC, HbS/a-thal) and 27 infants with other hemoglobin disorders were identified. Initial screening failed to identify 4 infants with sickle cell disease, but three of these were diagnosed on routine follow-up testing of infants suspected of having sickle cell trait. There were 32 false positive results, 27 of whom were confirmed to have a hemoglobinopathy trait on follow-up testing. The remaining 5 had normal hemoglobin.<5>
The yield in screening pregnant women for hemoglobin disorders depends on the risk profile of the population being tested. In one study, electrophoresis in combination with a complete blood count was performed on 298 African-American and Southeast Asian prenatal patients. Ninety-four women (31.5%) had a hemoglobin disorder (including sickle cell disease, sickle cell trait, hemoglobin E, a-thalassemia trait, b-thalassemia trait, hemoglobin H, and hemoglobin C).<6> In a larger study in a different community, similar tests were performed on 6,641 prenatal patients selected without regard to race or ethnic origin.<7> One hundred eighty-five women (3%) had sickle cell trait, 68 (1%) had hemoglobin C, 30 (0.5%) had b-thalassemia trait, and 17 (0.3%) had other disorders (hemoglobin E, a-thalassemia trait, hemoglobin H, hemoglobin E/b-thalassemia disease). These results were obtained by combining electrophoresis with red cell indices. When low mean corpuscular volume (MCV) has been used as the only screening test to detect thalassemia, the yield has been 0.3-0.5%.
Prenatal diagnosis of sickle cell disease and other hemoglobinopathies in the fetus has been aided by advances in techniques of obtaining and analyzing specimens. Early tests involved the analysis of fetal blood obtained by fetoscopy or placental aspiration.<8> Recent genetic advances, however, have provided a safer<9> and more practical method in which amniocytes are obtained by amniocentesis and chromosomal mutations are identified directly through recombinant DNA technology. These techniques are highly accurate in detecting sickle cell disease and certain forms of thalassemia.<8-12> Their principal disadvantage, however, is that amniocentesis cannot be performed safely until about 16 weeks’ gestation, thus delaying diagnosis and potential intervention until late in the second trimester. Chorionic villus sampling (CVS) is a means of obtaining tissue for DNA analysis as early as 8-10 weeks of gestation and is an established technique for prenatal diagnosis.<13,14> Several centers now offer the option of "early amniocentesis" (done several weeks earlier than conventional amniocentesis) as an alternative to CVS. Amniocentesis or CVS are part of the screening protocols for Down Syndrome (Chapter 8) and neural tube defects (Chapter 8).
Effectiveness
of Early Detection and TreatmentDetection of carrier status during pregnancy can
provide prospective parents with the option of testing the fetus for a
hemoglobinopathy. If the test is positive, they have the time to discuss
continuation of the pregnancy and to plan optimal care for their newborn.
Parents appear to act on this genetic information. About 70% of pregnant
women who were identified as b-thalassemia
carriers and received counselling referred their partners for testing.
Among couples at risk for sickle cell disease, about 60% consent to amniocentesis.<7>
If sickle cell disease is diagnosed in the fetus, about 50% of parents
elect therapeutic abortion.<11,21>
In a recent study, in Rochester, N.Y., 18,907
samples from pregnant women were screened for abnormal hemoglobin including
thalassemia and hemoglobin S. In 810
(4.3%), an abnormal hemoglobin was identified. Sixty-six percent occurred
in mothers unaware that they carried an abnormal hemoglobin, and 80% occurred
in mothers unaware that they were at risk for giving birth to a child with
a serious hematologic disorder. Eighty-six percent of mothers who received
counselling said they wanted their partner tested and 55% of partners were
tested. Seventy-seven pregnancies were identified as being at high risk
because the partner also was a carrier of an abnormal hemoglobin. Of these
77 pregnancies, the gestation was too advanced for prenatal diagnosis in
12
cases and the condition for which the pregnancy was at risk was too mild
for this service to be offered in 12
others. Prenatal diagnosis was offered in the remaining 53 pregnancies
and accepted by 25 couples (47%). Of 18
amniocenteses performed, 14
were at risk for sickling disorders and the remaining 4 for the Hb H disease
or Hb H with Hb E trait. Five fetuses were found to have clinically significant
hemoglobinopathies and one of these pregnancies was terminated.<22>
A comparison of the distribution of hemoglobinopathies detected in the
Rochester, N.Y. study with screening results reported from Hamilton, Ontario<23>
shows significant differences in the spectrum of abnormalities detected.
Those differences may reflect different ethnic mixes in Canada and the
U.S. or may be partly due to ascertainment bias since most referrals in
the Hamilton study were for investigation of low MCV.
|
|
|
|
| Hb S trait |
|
|
| Hb C trait |
|
|
| b-thalassemia trait |
|
|
| Hb E trait |
|
|
| Hb D or G trait |
|
|
| db-thal trait |
|
|
| a-thalassemia trait |
|
|
| Others |
|
|
| TOTALS |
|
|
There is evidence from some European communities with a high prevalence of b-thalassemia that the birth rate of affected infants declined significantly following the implementation of routine prenatal screening,<8,24,25> and other data suggest a similar trend in some North American communities that have introduced community education and testing for thalassemia. This decline may reflect more than one factor, possibly including 1) a general decline in birth rate; 2) termination of pregnancies with affected fetuses; and 3) "at risk" couples choosing not to have children.
Since hemoglobinopathies occur among all ethnic and racial groups, efforts at targeting specific high-risk groups for newborn screening inevitably miss some affected individuals due to difficulties in properly assigning race or ethnic origin in the newborn nursery. In one study of 528,711 newborns, parental race, as requested on a screening form, was found to be inaccurate or incomplete in 30% of cases.<5> Proponents of selective screening of high-risk populations emphasize that, especially in geographic areas with a small population at risk, cost effectiveness is compromised and considerable expense incurred in screening large numbers of low-risk newborns to identify the rare individuals with sickle cell disease or other uncommon hemoglobin disorders. Studies supporting this argument have compared universal screening to no screening, not to targeted screening. Recent research that accounts for the additional procedural and administrative costs of targeted screening suggests that universal screening may be the more cost effective alternative to targeted screening.
There has been considerable debate over the value of sickle screening and screening for other hemoglobinopathies in persons of reproductive age. Critics cite evidence that sickle cell screening programs in the past have failed to educate patients and the public adequately about the significant differences between sickle cell trait and sickle cell disease. This has resulted in unnecessary anxiety for carriers and inappropriate labelling by insurers and employers. In addition, there is no evidence that counselling, however comprehensive, will be remembered throughout the individual’s reproductive life, influence partner selection, alter use of prenatal testing, or ultimately reduce the rate of births of affected children. Proponents argue that these outcomes should not be used as measures of effectiveness since the goal of genetic counselling is to facilitate informed decision making by prospective parents. In this regard, clinicians are responsible for making the individual aware of the diagnosis, the risk to future offspring, and the recommended methods to reduce that risk, regardless of the strength of the evidence that such counselling reduces the number of affected offspring.
Recommendations
of OthersScreening of older children and young adults is not universally recommended. Some U.S. states require sickle cell screening of school children, but many medical authorities have advised against this practice.
In Canada, thalassemia screening programs for carrier detection and prenatal diagnosis targeted at known high-risk groups, are currently available in Montreal, Quebec and in Hamilton, Ontario, though large communities at risk are present elsewhere in Canada. Hemoglobinopathy DNA referral diagnostic laboratories are available in Calgary, Hamilton and Montreal, where prenatal diagnosis from chorionic villus sampling or amniocentesis is also available. In Hamilton, Ontario, the Regional Hemoglobinopathy Reference Laboratory investigates several thousand cases each year. Over a 20-year period, this laboratory has tested over 38,000 samples, referred because of an abnormal CBC (hypochromia, microcytosis or mild anemia). Of these 38,000 referrals, more than 7,300 were carriers of hemoglobin variants or thalassemia, showing that the spectrum of hemoglobinopathies in Canada differs significantly from that of the U.S.
Conclusions
and RecommendationsIn all neonates from high risk ethnic groups, newborn screening for hemoglobinopathies is recommended, using dried filter paper blood spots (A Recommendation). Cellulose acetate electrophoresis or thin layer isoelectric focusing are currently the preferred screening tests, with citrate agar electrophoresis or high-performance liquid chromatography in a reference laboratory for confirmation. These methods may be superseded by more rapid and accurate techniques in future.
Unanswered
Questions (Research Agenda) Evidence Acknowledgements
Full Citation
Link to Structured Abstract of this review
Link to Summary Table of this review
Link to Selected References list of this review
Reprinted in modified format by the Canadian
Task Force on Preventive Health Care
with permission.
For any technical issues please contact: webmaster@ctfphc.org
Original Copyright
© 1994 Minister of Supply and Services Canada.
Last modified March 30, 1998.
